Kodansha's Kanji guide VS. Casio XD-470   August 3, 2006

The best kanji book   November 19, 2005

This book is a work of art   May 6, 2004

G.


Good All-Around Product   September 25, 2001
  2 out of 2 found this review helpful

I have used this guide for some years now, and I find it to be the most useful Japanese dictionary that I have. While of course it cannot compete with Nelson on the number of entries, or kanji for that matter, it is a good deal smaller than Nelson and I can take it to work with me without problem. For business uses and the popular press in general I have rarely run across a word that I could not find in here. And it's so durable!

Some may balk at the traditional radical order of the Kanji, but it's what I was used to, more or less, so I find it convenient. I'm not so sure why the publishers felt it necessary to put the stroke order in - shouldn't you already know that if you're past Japanese 001? I'd recommend deleting it in the interest of adding more entries, but that's my only complaint.


Good Reference for Beginners   May 4, 2000
  9 out of 9 found this review helpful

Kodansha's Compact Kanji Guide is an excellent reference for beginners learning the Japanese written language. It contains all the Jooyou Kanji (the official list of 1,950 essential Kanjis of the Japanese Ministry of Education) and some 18,000 compounds, focussing particularly on those appearing frequently in Japanese mass media. In particular, great emphasis is laid on compounds pertaining to the business world. Beyond this, however, the scope of this book is fairly limited. It contains few literary words, and, in general, too few characters and compounds to be of any use to the advanced learner at all. In fact, the book is surprisingly large and heavy for the quantity of content it contains.

The On and Kun readings of the kanji are provided in kana; in particular, the On readings appear in katakana, so the reader must be familiar with this syllabary. Pronunciation of compounds are also given, with multiple or irregular readings indicated. The dictionary makes little use of romaji. Although the definitions provided are fairly useful, few usage notes are provided making the dictionary less useful for Japanese composition. Nevertheless, it is very handy for the beginning student to check the meanings of unfamiliar words.

The arrangement of the characters more-or-less follow the traditional Chinese arrangement according to radicals, although, unfortunately, certain variants usually considered to be the same radical are separated into different radicals in this dictionary, and, hence, some characters appear in a location different from that where one would find it in a traditional character dictionary. Three indices provided allows one to locate a given character by radical, stroke-count and pronunciation. Each kanji also has its stroke order displayed for the convenience of the learner.

The book is physically well produced, with a vinyl-type soft cover and fairly thick paper of high quality that takes wear fairly well. The print is clear, and the head characters are printed very large (about a centimetre square) so that its composition can be clearly seen. Although the book is by no means large, I would not myself have describe it as 'compact' as its title suggests.

A beginning learner of written Japanese could do worse than to acquire this book, although, as an intermediate learner myself, I find that the scope of the book is not really very sufficient, more often than not, the character or compound that I go to look up is not in the book. For those of us who are not businessmen, the Kanji Guide's focus on financial and business vocabulary would be somewhat annoying. In short, then, Kodansha's Compact Kanji Guide is great reference, but for beginners only.